The default: work state withholds, home state gives credit
With no agreement between the two states, you can end up with a withholding line for the work state and a resident return in your home state. New Jersey’s rule is typical: the credit for tax paid to another state cannot be more than what New Jersey would have charged on that income. So the total is roughly the higher of the two states’ taxes, not both added together. Each state writes its own credit rules, so check the one where you live.
Reciprocity: you only pay your home state
When two states have a reciprocal agreement, wages of a resident of one state are not subject to withholding in the other. You give your employer a form and only your home state’s tax is withheld. The agreements differ by state. Pennsylvania’s list is Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, New Jersey, Virginia and West Virginia. Virginia’s is the District of Columbia, Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and West Virginia. Ohio’s is Michigan, Indiana, Kentucky, West Virginia and Pennsylvania. Michigan’s is Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Minnesota, Ohio and Wisconsin. Illinois’s form names Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan and Wisconsin.
The forms people get wrong
A New Jersey resident working for a Pennsylvania employer gives the employer Form REV-419EX. A Pennsylvania resident working for a New Jersey employer gives Form NJ-165. A resident of a reciprocal state working in Illinois uses IL-W-5-NR, and in Virginia uses VA-4. If the wrong state withholds anyway, you do not lose the money for good. Virginia tells you to file Form 763-S for a refund. New Jersey says a New Jersey resident who had Pennsylvania tax withheld files a Pennsylvania return to get it back.
Worked example: a $60,000 salary
Using this site’s annualized state estimates for a single filer: Pennsylvania tax on $60,000 is about $1,842 at 3.07%, and New Jersey tax is about $1,767. A New Jersey resident working in Pennsylvania who files REV-419EX pays about $1,767 to New Jersey and nothing to Pennsylvania. Without the form, Pennsylvania withholds about $1,842 and the worker has to file a Pennsylvania return to get it refunded. Now take a New Jersey resident working in Virginia. Virginia’s list does not include New Jersey, so no agreement applies. Virginia tax on $60,000 is about $2,636. New Jersey’s credit covers its own $1,767 of tax. The worker pays about Virginia’s $2,636 in total, and nothing extra to New Jersey on those wages.
What this guide does not cover
Remote work, local city taxes and workers who split time between states have extra rules, and some states tax wages by where the employer is located. Those need the state’s own guidance. A move mid-year can also create two part-year resident returns. Treat the numbers above as estimates of how the tax splits, not a prediction of what your employer will withhold.
Try it with your own numbers in the state paycheck calculators.
Quick answers
How do I stop a second state from withholding on my wages?
If your home state and work state have a reciprocal agreement, give your employer the work state’s exemption form. Without an agreement, the work state generally still withholds and you claim a credit on your home state return.
What if the wrong state took tax out of my paycheck?
Ask payroll to correct it going forward, then request a refund. Virginia points to Form 763-S, and New Jersey says to file a Pennsylvania return to recover Pennsylvania tax withheld in error.
Do I file two state tax returns?
Often yes, one nonresident return for the state where you worked and one resident return for your home state. With a reciprocal agreement and the right form on file, you usually file only the home state return.
Does a reciprocity agreement cover city or local taxes?
Not necessarily. Agreements deal with state income tax withholding. Local earned income and city taxes follow their own rules, so check with the city or your employer.
Sources
- Pennsylvania DOR: employer withholding
- NJ Division of Taxation: PA/NJ reciprocal agreement
- NJ Division of Taxation: credit for taxes paid to other jurisdictions
- Virginia Tax: reciprocity
- Michigan Treasury: withholding reciprocity examples
- Illinois DOR: Form IL-W-5-NR
- Ohio Department of Taxation: employer withholding FAQ



