PaystubLedgerSearch
Menu
EQUITY COMPENSATION · 2026
Bonuses, overtime and extra pay

RSU Tax Withholding: Why 22% Often Isn’t Enough

When restricted stock units vest, the market value of the shares is wages, taxed the same year as your salary. Employers usually withhold federal income tax at a flat 22%. If your top bracket is higher, that is not enough.

RSUs are taxed on the vest date

Nothing is taxed when RSUs are granted. Tax is triggered when they vest, based on the fair market value of the shares that day. A vest of 400 shares at $50 is $20,000 of ordinary income, shown on your W-2 and added to your salary for the year.

Withholding is a flat 22%, plus FICA

The IRS treats the vest as supplemental wages. Employers can withhold a flat 22% for federal income tax, or 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million in the year. Social Security and Medicare also apply, so on a $20,000 vest, 22% is $4,400 and FICA is $1,530 if you are under the wage base. State tax is withheld too.

In a state with no income tax, that is $5,930 of tax on the $20,000, so you keep shares worth about $14,070. At $50 a share, the company holds back roughly 119 of the 400 shares, with the exact count depending on rounding and any state tax.

Selling shares to pay it

Most companies settle the tax by withholding shares. With net share settlement the company keeps shares worth the tax and delivers the rest. With sell-to-cover, brokers sell enough shares to raise the cash. Either way, you receive fewer shares than vested, and the tax is paid from the stock, not from your paycheck.

The shortfall depends on your bracket

The flat rate does not know your income. If your income puts the vest in the 32% bracket, the true federal tax on $20,000 is $6,400 instead of $4,400, a $2,000 gap you owe when you file. At 24% the gap is $400.

Federal income tax on a $20,000 vest against 22% withheld, by bracket the vest falls in
Bracket for the vestFederal tax on $20,000Withheld at 22%Gap at filing
22%$4,400$4,400$0
24%$4,800$4,400$400
32%$6,400$4,400$2,000
35%$7,000$4,400$2,600
37%$7,400$4,400$3,000

Income tax only. Social Security, Medicare and state tax are separate.

Two salaries, two outcomes

A single filer earning $120,000 who vests $20,000 starts in the 22% bracket and crosses into 24%. The extra federal tax on the vest is $4,764, so 22% leaves a gap of $364. A single filer earning $230,000 has the whole vest in the 32% bracket: the extra tax is $6,400 and the gap is $2,000.

FICA changes too. At $230,000 the Social Security wage base of $184,500 is already used up, so the vest owes no Social Security. It owes $290 of Medicare plus $180 of Additional Medicare on the $20,000. At $120,000 the vest owes the full $1,240 of Social Security and the same $290 of Medicare.

Close the gap before it becomes a bill

A reasonable fix is to raise your W-4 withholding or make an estimated payment. Multiply the expected vest by the difference between your bracket and 22%, then spread that amount over the paychecks left in the year using the extra withholding line in Step 4 of Form W-4. The IRS safe harbor helps too: you generally owe no underpayment penalty if the balance due is under $1,000, or if your withholding covers 90% of this year’s tax or 100% of last year’s (110% if last year’s adjusted gross income was above $150,000).

After vest: capital gains

The value at vest becomes your cost basis. If you sell later for more, the gain is a capital gain, short-term if you hold a year or less. If you sell at the same price as the vest, there is no further gain or loss. Keep your vest confirmations so your broker’s basis is correct.

Try it with your own numbers in the bonus tax calculator.

Quick answers

Are RSUs taxed when they vest or when I sell?

When they vest. The fair market value on the vest date is ordinary income. A later sale creates a separate capital gain or loss measured from that value.

Why is my RSU withholding only 22%?

Employers use the flat supplemental wage rate, which is 22% unless your supplemental wages exceed $1 million. It is a withholding rate, not your final tax rate.

Do RSUs count toward Social Security tax?

Yes. Vested RSUs are wages for FICA, and they count toward the $184,500 Social Security wage base for the year.

Does RSU income show up on my W-2?

Yes. The value at vest is wages, so it is part of your W-2 pay and the tax withheld is part of your W-2 withholding. Compare the totals with your vest confirmations when the form arrives.

Sources

Use the numbers: Open the paycheck calculator to apply these ideas to a salary or hourly rate. The result is an annualized estimate; your employer’s actual withholding can differ.

Yassin

Yassin is a software developer who built PaystubLedger. As its editor, he checks every number against the source before it goes live.

About Yassin

Keep reading

Related guides