How each type is taxed
The IRS describes traditional contributions as made with before-tax dollars and Roth contributions as made with after-tax dollars. Qualified Roth withdrawals, contributions and earnings, are not taxed. That means the account has been held at least five years and the withdrawal is on account of disability, death, or on or after age 59½. Traditional withdrawals are subject to federal and most state income taxes. The pay-now or pay-later choice is the whole difference.
Worked example: $80,000 salary, $6,000 a year
A single filer in Texas has $80,000 of wages and $8,770 of federal tax. Put $6,000 into a traditional 401(k) and federal tax falls to $7,450, a saving of $1,320. The net cost is $4,680, or $180.00 per biweekly check. Put the same $6,000 into a Roth and nothing changes in the tax. The cost is the full $6,000, or $230.77 per check. The take-home gap is $1,320 a year, about $50.77 per check. At this income the contribution sits in the 22% bracket, so the gap equals 22% of the contribution.
Same take-home, different account
Suppose you want the paycheck to drop by the same amount either way. Put $4,680 into a Roth and it costs $4,680 of take-home, just like the $6,000 traditional contribution. But the Roth account holds $4,680 and the traditional account holds $6,000. The traditional balance is bigger, and part of it belongs to the IRS later. Whether that is a better deal depends on whether your tax rate in retirement is higher or lower than your rate today.
One limit for both
The deferral limit is per person, not per plan, and it is shared. You can split between Roth and traditional if your plan offers both, but the combined total cannot pass the limit. For 2026 that limit is $24,500, with catch-up amounts for people 50 and older. Roth does not change your federal withholding. It gives no tax reduction now, so the check shrinks by the whole contribution.
What to weigh
Roth tends to suit people in a low bracket now who expect a higher one later. Traditional tends to suit people in a high bracket now who expect a lower one in retirement. Cash flow matters too. If your budget is tight, the traditional version leaves more in each check. If the plan has an employer match, both types can earn it. These are factors to weigh, not a recommendation for your situation.
Try it with your own numbers in the paycheck calculator.
Quick answers
Does a Roth 401(k) reduce my paycheck more than a traditional one?
Yes. A Roth contribution is made with after-tax dollars, so it reduces take-home by the full amount. A traditional contribution lowers income tax withholding, so it costs less than the amount saved.
Can I split my 401(k) between Roth and traditional?
Many plans allow it. If yours does, the combined contributions still cannot exceed the annual deferral limit, which is $24,500 for 2026.
Does a Roth 401(k) lower my federal withholding?
No. Roth deferrals are included in the wages used to calculate income tax, so withholding stays as if you had not contributed.
Are Roth 401(k) withdrawals always tax-free?
Only qualified withdrawals. The account must have been held at least five years, and the withdrawal must be due to disability, death, or on or after age 59½.



